Tradeoffs John Diefenbach

Real Independence: Why They Want You Dependent

Nobody talks about real independence anymore—the kind that makes you ungovernable. Every convenience you adopt is a skill you lose. Wake up.

You know what nobody talks about anymore? Real independence. Not the kind they sell you in commercials with trucks driving through deserts or some guy in designer jeans standing on a mountain. I’m talking about the kind of independence that makes you fundamentally ungovernable. The kind that means when everything goes sideways—and it will—you’re not standing there with your hand out, waiting for someone to save you.

I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately because I see people everywhere claiming they value freedom, but then I watch them hand over every single decision in their lives to someone else. What to eat? Ask the app. Where to go? Check the reviews. How to think? Turn on the news. What to believe? Well, that’s what the experts are for, right? That’s exactly what they want you to think.

Real independence isn’t comfortable. It’s not supposed to be. It means making hard choices and living with the consequences. It means doing your own research, forming your own opinions, and accepting that sometimes you’re going to be wrong—but at least you’ll be wrong on your own terms. I’d rather be wrong following my own judgment than right because I blindly followed someone else’s. Because here’s the thing: when you outsource your decision-making, you’re not just giving up control. You’re giving up the ability to even know what control feels like.

The world wants you dependent. Dependent on systems, dependent on experts, dependent on conveniences that can be turned off with a switch. And every time you choose comfort over capability, every time you choose convenience over competence, you’re trading away a piece of your independence. Today, I want to talk about what it really means to be independent in a world designed to make you anything but.


The Illusion of Choice

Here’s something that’ll make you uncomfortable: most of the “choices” you think you’re making every day? You’re not making them. They’re being made for you, and you’re just selecting from the predetermined options someone else laid out. It’s like being in a restaurant where you can order anything you want—as long as it’s on the menu they wrote.

Think about your phone for a second. You “chose” it, right? But did you really? You chose from maybe three or four options that were marketed to you through channels you didn’t select, with features you didn’t know you needed until they told you. The operating system? Someone else decided that. The apps you can use? Approved by someone else. What information you see? Curated by algorithms you’ll never understand. You’re making choices within a framework you had no hand in building.

I’m not saying don’t have a phone—I have one too, though I’ve stripped it down to basics and I’m under no illusion about what it is: a tracking device that occasionally makes calls. What I’m saying is be honest about it. Don’t confuse selecting from predetermined options with actual independence.

Real choice means you could walk away from all of it tomorrow and be fine. Not comfortable, maybe. Not convenient. But fine. Alive. Capable. That’s the test: if the system disappeared tomorrow, would you know how to function? If the answer is no, you’re not independent. You’re just a well-fed dependent.

The Comfort Trap

The system loves when you’re comfortable because comfortable people don’t ask questions. Comfortable people don’t learn new skills. Comfortable people don’t challenge anything because why would you rock the boat when the boat has air conditioning and streaming services?

But comfort is a trap. Every convenience you adopt is a skill you lose. Every system you rely on is a potential point of failure. I’m not saying live in the woods eating pine cones—though I could if I had to—I’m saying understand the tradeoff. When you order food instead of cooking, you’re trading time for capability. Do it enough, and you forget how to cook. When you rely on GPS for every trip, you lose the ability to navigate. When you trust experts to tell you what to think about everything, you lose the ability to think critically.

Independence means keeping those capabilities sharp even when you don’t need them. Especially when you don’t need them. Because the time you need them is exactly when they won’t be available.


Following Your Own Path

I’ve made a lot of decisions in my life that people thought were crazy. Moving off-grid. Stockpiling supplies. Learning skills that most people consider obsolete. Not trusting the official narrative on, well, pretty much anything. And you know what? Some of those decisions probably were a little crazy. But they were my decisions, made with my judgment, based on my research.

That’s what independence looks like. It doesn’t mean you’re always right. It means you’re willing to be wrong on your own terms rather than right by accident because you followed the crowd.

I remember when I first started questioning the official stories about things. People looked at me like I’d grown a second head. “Just trust the experts,” they’d say. “Why would they lie?” And I’d think: why wouldn’t they? Who benefits when you stop asking questions? Not you, that’s for sure.

But here’s the thing about following your own path: you have to actually do the work. You can’t just be contrarian for the sake of it. That’s not independence; that’s just being difficult. Real independence means doing your own research, checking your sources, thinking through the implications, and being willing to change your mind when the evidence changes. It means having principles that guide your decisions, not just reactions against what everyone else is doing.

The Research Nobody Does

Everyone says “do your own research” but almost nobody actually does it. They read a headline, maybe skim an article, check what their preferred echo chamber thinks about it, and call that research. That’s not research. That’s confirmation bias with extra steps.

Real research is uncomfortable. It means reading things you disagree with. It means considering possibilities you don’t like. It means admitting when you don’t know something instead of pretending you do. It means tracing claims back to their sources and evaluating whether those sources are trustworthy.

I’ve got filing cabinets full of documents. I’ve read reports that would bore most people to tears. I’ve followed footnotes down rabbit holes that led to other footnotes. And yeah, sometimes I’ve ended up at conclusions that sound crazy to other people. But at least I know how I got there. I can show my work. Can you?

Independence means not taking anyone’s word for anything—including mine. It means developing your own ability to evaluate information, spot manipulation, and think critically. And that’s a skill that takes practice, like any other.


The Price of Self-Reliance

Let me be straight with you: being truly independent costs something. It costs time. It costs money. It costs convenience. It costs social acceptance. People think you’re weird when you don’t just go along with things. They get uncomfortable when you ask questions they’ve never considered.

I’ve lost friends over this stuff. Not because I pushed my views on them—I don’t care what other people believe as long as they leave me alone—but because my independence made them uncomfortable. It held up a mirror to their dependence, and they didn’t like what they saw.

But here’s what I’ve gained: I sleep well at night knowing that my survival doesn’t depend on systems staying functional. I’m not worried about supply chain disruptions because I’ve got supplies. I’m not worried about gas prices because I can get by without it if I need to. I’m not worried about what the news says because I don’t trust it anyway.

That peace of mind? You can’t buy it. You have to build it, one decision at a time.

The Skills That Matter

Independence isn’t just about stockpiling stuff—though that’s part of it. It’s about capabilities. Can you grow food? Can you purify water? Can you fix things when they break? Can you navigate without technology? Can you make decisions without consulting a dozen apps and websites?

These aren’t just survival skills. They’re independence skills. Every capability you have is something you don’t need someone else for. Every skill you master is a piece of freedom.

I spend time every week maintaining and building these capabilities. I’m not doing it because I think the apocalypse is coming tomorrow—though it could be—I’m doing it because being capable feels good. It’s empowering. It’s the opposite of the learned helplessness that modern society encourages.

And here’s the bonus: once you start building real skills, you see through the fake ones. You realize how much of modern education and expertise is just credentialism—pieces of paper that say you sat through some classes, not that you can actually do anything useful.


The Freedom to Fail

Here’s something they don’t tell you about independence: you’re going to screw up. A lot. And that’s actually a feature, not a bug.

When you’re making your own decisions, following your own path, doing your own research, you’re going to get things wrong sometimes. I’ve made mistakes. I’ve prepared for things that didn’t happen and missed things I should have seen coming. I’ve spent money on preps that turned out to be less useful than I thought and ignored things that would have been more valuable.

But every mistake taught me something. Every failure made me more capable. Because when you fail on your own terms, you learn real lessons. When you fail because you were following someone else’s advice, you just learn not to trust that person—but you don’t learn the actual skill.

The system doesn’t want you to fail. It wants you to stay in your lane, follow the rules, do what you’re told. Because if you never fail, you never learn to recover. You never build resilience. You never discover what you’re actually capable of when things go wrong.

Building Resilience Through Consequences

This is the part that makes people uncomfortable: real independence means living with real consequences. If I make a bad decision about my preps, I might go hungry. If I mess up my water filtration system, I might get sick. If I misread a situation, I might put myself in danger.

And you know what? That’s how it should be. Consequences are information. They’re feedback. They’re how you learn what works and what doesn’t. The modern world tries to insulate you from consequences—until suddenly it can’t, and then people are completely unprepared to deal with them.

I’d rather face small consequences regularly, learn from them, and build my capability, than be protected from everything until one day I face consequences I’m completely unprepared for. That’s the difference between someone who’s actually independent and someone who just thinks they are.


The Long Game

Independence isn’t something you achieve once and then you’re done. It’s not a destination. It’s a practice, a discipline, a way of living. Every day, you’re either building your independence or eroding it. Every choice is either making you more capable or more dependent.

I look at how I live now compared to ten years ago, and the difference is stark. I’m more skilled. More prepared. More capable of handling whatever comes. But I’m not done. I’ll never be done. Because the world keeps changing, new threats emerge, old systems decay, and staying independent means staying ahead of the curve.

The people who think they’ll just figure it out when they need to? They won’t. When crisis hits, you don’t rise to the occasion—you fall to your level of preparation. And if your level of preparation is “I’ll just go to the store” or “the government will help,” you’re in for a rough time.

Real independence means playing the long game. It means making decisions today that pay off years from now. It means sacrificing convenience now for capability later. It means being the person everyone else thinks is paranoid—right up until the moment they need exactly what you’ve been preparing for.


Living on Your Own Terms

At the end of the day, independence is about one thing: living on your own terms. Not society’s terms. Not the system’s terms. Not the terms dictated by convenience or comfort or what everyone else is doing. Your terms.

That means knowing what you value and being willing to pay the price to maintain it. For me, it’s freedom from dependence on systems I don’t trust. It’s the ability to make my own choices and live with my own consequences. It’s being able to look at whatever’s happening in the world and know that I’ll be okay because I’ve prepared, I’ve learned, I’ve built capability.

Is it always comfortable? No. Is it always convenient? Definitely not. Do people think I’m crazy? Absolutely. But I sleep well at night, I’m not afraid of what’s coming, and I answer to nobody but myself. That’s worth more than any amount of comfort or convenience or social acceptance.

The choice is yours. You can keep outsourcing your decisions, your thinking, your capability to systems and experts and algorithms. You can stay comfortable and dependent and hope nothing ever goes wrong. Or you can start building real independence—the kind that means you’re fundamentally ungovernable, fundamentally capable, fundamentally free.

Just remember: the time to start building independence is before you need it. Because when you need it, it’s already too late.

Do your own research. Make your own choices. Live with your own consequences. That’s what real independence looks like, and that’s exactly what they don’t want you to have.

Stay Updated

Subscribe to our YouTube channel and follow us on social media for the latest episodes, behind-the-scenes content, and updates.